WHY WINDOWS EMULATION AND VIRTUALIZATION ARE SO IMPORTANTYes, we know, Wine is NOT an Emulator, but then, what is it? Think of Wine as a compatibility layer for running Windows programmes. Wine does not require Microsoft Windows, as it is set up to fake a windows environment on your Linux, Mac or Solarus computer. Wine can use native Windows DLLs if they are available. It provides both a development toolkit for porting Windows source code to Unix as well as a program loader, allowing many unmodified Windows programs to run on x86-based Unixes, including Linux, FreeBSD, Mac OS X, and Solaris.
There is a commercial alternative to Wine: Codeweavers. As usual, the commercial versions of Linux operating systems and software are a bit more user-friendly, but not all that much. Moreover, there are virtualization programmes, of which we for instance use the free version of VMWare tu virtualize Windows XP and 98.
A lot of people in popular discussion forums keep
thinking that Wine and other Windows Emulators and Virtulization programmes are
"the last thing that Linux needs" or that it is "not
important". We are listing some info here that is supposed to thoroughly
defeat these and other claims. Arguments are primarily copied and adapted from WineHQ.
Five key points:
Supply diversificationDiversifying your supply is universally considered to be an important aspect of risk management.
Yet, The US Department of Justice has "found" that Microsoft Windows is run by more than 95% of personal computers. Even taking Apple's Mac OS into account, Microsoft Windows is still present on more than 80% of computers, and this is likely also true in most other countries, not just in the US. Thus governments, companies and home users all over the world ultimately depend on a single provider: Microsoft.
The question is not whether Microsoft has evil intents (which it does not), or whether it may go out of business just like so many "solid" banks have recently done. Moreover, does Microsoft always match your needs. If Microsoft is not interested in catering to your needs, then you have no other provider to turn to. That is unacceptable for a society.
Large homogeneous populations are a risk to society
Another aspect is that such large homogeneous populations are dangerous to society. The Irish learnt this the hard way when their potato crop was destroyed by a fungus, causing the 1845 "Potato Famine" and killing more than a million people (about 10% of the population). In a large homogeneous population, all individuals share the same vulnerabilities. Find one vulnerability and you can annihilate the whole population. Since then, we, as a society, have learnt our lesson. Or have we?
As mentioned above, Microsoft Windows is run on an overwhelming proportion of personal computers. Even taking into account the variations between different versions of Windows, mostly between Windows 9x and the Windows NT family, this represents a large homogeneous population. One on which most governments, most businesses, and many households depend.
The elements of this population, like all other complex systems, are not miraculously exempt from vulnerabilities. The Code Red epidemic of the summer of 2001 is there to remind us of that. Code Red did what any "virus" presented with a large homogeneous population would do: it infected more than 359.000 computers in just the first day. Fortunately, it infected a less common member of the Windows family and was quite harmless: it did not randomly corrupt files or format your hard-drive. , 
It is only a matter of time before a more virulent worm appears. The only way to decrease its impact is to diversify the OS population. This issue is now considered serious enough that security analysts are calling our reliance on Microsoft Windows a threat to national security.
Because it is an alternate implementation of the Win32 API and runs on top of a completely different OS, Wine and other emulators don't have the same flaws and thus can provide this needed diversity, but virtualization programmes do, since they still run a version of Windows.
Any Windows replacement must run Windows applicationsThe dependency is not so much on Microsoft Windows as it is on Windows applications. Boxed off-the-shelf applications, games, in-house applications, vertical market applications, are what prevents users, companies and governments from switching to another operating system. Even if 90% of the needs of most users are taken care of if you can provide them with an office suite, an email client, a browser, and a media player, then there will still be a remaining 10% of their needs, potentially critical needs, that are not met. Unfortunately these remaining 10% are spread across a wide spectrum of applications: thousands of applications running the gamut from games to specialized accounting software for French farms, via Italian encyclopedias, German tax software, child education software, banking software, in-house software representing years of development, etc. It is the availability of all this software that makes Windows so compelling and its monopoly so strong. No platform will become mainstream unless it runs a significant portion of that software and lets individuals, companies and governments preserve their investments in that software.
Chicken-and-egg problem for Linux on the desktopThis brings us to the chicken and egg issue of Linux and MAC on the desktops. Until Linux and Macs can provide equivalents for the above applications, their marketshares on the desktop will stagnate. But until the marketshares of Linux and Macs on the desktop rise, no vendor will develop applications for Linux and relatively limited for Macs. How does one break this vicious circle?
Again, Wine and similar programmes can provide an answer. By letting users reuse the Windows applications they have invested time and money in, Wine and alikes dramatically lower the barrier that prevents users from switching to Linux and Macs. This then makes it possible for Linux and Mac to take off on the desktop, which increases their market shares in that segment. In turn, this makes it viable for companies to produce Linux and Mac versions of their applications, and for new products to come out just for the Linux market.
This reasoning could be dismissed easily if Wine and
alikes were only capable of running Solitaire. However it can run Microsoft
Office, ILWIS, multi-media applications
such as QuickTime
and Windows Media Player,
and even games such as Max
Payne or Spore.
Wine benefitsLast but not least, Wine can provide benefits over Windows right now:
NATURE WORLDWIDE is the official website of the World Institute for Conservation and Environment, WICE. It is an integrated network of web sites dealing with different topics on nature, nature conservation and natural resources management. Read here why we created Nature Worldwide. Our Methodology explains how we produced our information. Our Site Map helps you find your way in the website. We made this website out of passion for conservation. We spent our own salaries and free time to gather the information and publish it on these websites, in total valuing hundreds of thousands of dollars of professional time. Nobody pays us to do this. We simply want to contribute to conservation. If you appreciate our work, PLEASE visit our site Adopt A Ranger and see how you can make a difference for conservation most effectively: By paying one day of the salary of a ranger, you will make a difference in conserving the lives of thousands of birds, other critters and entire forests. check our sitemap. Enjoy!
NATURE DU MONDE est le site Web officiel du World Institute for Conservation and Environment, WICE, C'est une collection intégrée de sites web qui traitent avec des sujets différents sur nature, conservation de la nature et gestion des ressources naturelles. Lisez ici pourquoi nous avons créé Nature de Monde. Notre Methodologie explique comme nous avons produit nos renseignements. Notre Site Map vous aide trouver votre entrée dans le site web. Beaucoup de plaisir!
NATURALEZA DEL MUNDO es la página Web oficial del World Institute for Conservation and Environment, WICE, Es una red de páginas Web tratando de temas diferentes relacionados a la naturaleza, la conservación el manejo de recursos naturales, parques nacionales y áreas protegidas. Lea aqui porqué hicimos Naturaleza del Mundo. Nuestra Methodología explica como produjimos la información. Nuestro Mapa del sitio le ayuda encontrar su información en nuestra página web. Disfrute!
NATUREZA DO MUNDO é o Web site oficial do World Institute for Conservation and Environment, WICE, Es uma red de páginas Web tratando de temas diferentes relacionados à natureza, la conservação el manejo de recursos naturaleiss, parques nacionais y áreas protegidas. Lea aqui porqué creamos Natureza do Mundo. Nossa Methodología explica como produjimos a informação. Nosso Mapa do sitio le ayuda encontrar sua informação no web site. Desfrute!
NATUR DER GANZEN WELT ist, die offiziellen Website der World Institute for Conservation and Environment, WICE. Es ist ein einheitliches Netzwerk von Web Sites, über Themen wie Natur, Natur-Schutz und natürlichem Ressourcen Quellen Hege. Lesen Sie hier warum wir Natur der ganzen Welt gemacht haben. Un
NATUUR UIT ALLE STREKEN is, de officiële Website van het World Institute for Conservation and Environment, WICE. Het is een geïntegreerd Netwerk van websites, over Natuur, Natuurbescherming en het beheer van natuurlijke hulpbronnen. Lesen Sie hier warum wir Natuur uit alle Streken gemacht haben. Onze pagina Methode legt uit, hoe we onze informatie vergaarden. Onze Site Map helpt u op weg door onze website.
WICE is a worldwide non-government non-profit organization that contributes to the conservation of nature. While it works on a many issues related to the conservation of nature and the protection of the environment, it is particularly committed to the conservation of national parks and other protected areas.
Please read the disclaimer.